Muscadelle and Muscadet

by David
(Port Elliot)

Muscadet Sur Lie

Muscadet Sur Lie

David of Port Elliot asks:



I find there is confusion over the difference between muscadet and muscadelle.

As far as I am aware the muscadet produced near the mouth of the Loire is vinified from the variety mélon de Bourgogne, not muscadelle as I was once told.



I have tried most appellations of muscadet: all seem to be neutral or subtle in aroma.



Then we have muscat! What say you, Darby?



Darby replies:
Yes, they are two quite distinct varieties. Melon, or Melon de Bourgogne is the variety behind Muscadet which is really the style. In spite of its name it is no longer grown in Burgundy, having been banned from there in the Sixteenth Century by Phillip II of Spain and the Duke of Burgundy, who due to his marriage to Mary I, was also King of England for a couple of years. After Mary's death her little sister Elizabeth knocked Phillip's proposal back so the Spanish hold on the English Crown was short-lived.

Melon has a few synonyms including Gamay Blanc and Muscadet, although the latter term is more commonly used to describe the wine rather than the grape.


Melon is as you say grown in the lower reaches of the Loire to make Muscadet wine. These are crisp, low acid, low alcohol and fairly light bodied. Some of the wines are given extended contact with the skins during fermentation and thus gain more body and flavour. They are labelled Sur Lie. Great wine for fried seafood. Not much Melon is grown outside the Loire region.


Muscadelle and Melon share Gouias Blanc as a parent but they are quite distinct. They are not closely related to the rather large Muscat family, nor to the rare red variety Muscardin used in the Rhone.

See this page for more about Muscadelle.

Comments for Muscadelle and Muscadet

Click here to add your own comments

Aug 05, 2018
Viva Melon de Bourgogne
by: Mike Hayes

I agree Darby I tried both on my Churchill Tour and Melon de Bourgogne is Muscadet.

Muscadelle is from the Muscat family. The vines are miles apart and the Muscadelle is large berry and distinctively floral where Melon de Bourgogne is neutral and at best slightly nutty in retro nasal activity.

Muscadet is a smaller berry and tighter bunch. Both wines when made well are quite good. I think Muscadelle has origins from the Eygptian wine growing region taken to France by the Greeks.

The other point is the Muscat family is quite diverse and found all over Europe. I think Melon de Bourgogne is an interesting choice for sparkling wines and often blended with its neighbouring Chenin Blanc.
Ciao
Mike Hayes

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Ask Vinodiversity.

Keep in touch with Vinodiversity

Just enter your details below and you will receive an occasional newsletter letting you know all about the alternative varietal wine scene in Australia and beyond.
Email

Name

Then

Don't worry -- your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Vinodiversity News.

Wine map of Italy

See the best wine maps from


See also Vinodiversity's Wine Map Store on Amazon